Italian Leather Mary-Jane Flat
Merlot
New customers: get $20 off $100+ — enter your email and we'll send a referral link instantly.
Referral link sent! Check your inbox.
The $20 discount applies automatically when you click the link.
Our Review
GoodThe Italian Leather Mary-Jane Flat earns solid ratings with most buyers satisfied with the purchase. At $80, it sits well below comparable products at traditional retailers — Quince footwear is made at factories in Spain and Italy using the same leather and construction methods as European dress shoe brands at 3–4× the price.
Based on 46 verified buyer reviews on Quince.com, the Italian Leather Mary-Jane Flat scores 4.33 out of 5. Buyers have mixed feedback — most are happy with the quality, but fit and sizing inconsistencies are the most common complaints.
Pros
- Strong price-to-quality ratio for the category
- No retail middleman — priced at or below wholesale for comparable quality
- 1 color options available
- New customers get $20 off $100+ via referral link
Cons
- Some buyers note inconsistencies in fit or finish
- Online-only — no brick-and-mortar stores to try before buying
- Sizing runs differently across categories; check the size guide
Bottom Line
The Italian Leather Mary-Jane Flat is worth considering if the price and category fit your needs. New customers save an additional $20 off $100+ with our referral link — enter your email above and receive it instantly.